Community feedback

• 

  P

  AlejandroCavita•30

  @AlejandroCavitaPosted 14 days ago

  Code Review

  1. Does the solution include semantic HTML?

  Yes, but there is room for improvement.

  • The code uses semantic elements like <section>, which is a good practice.
  • Potential improvement:
    • Using <main> instead of <div class="container"> would improve semantics since the QR code component is the main content of the page.
    • The <h1> is correctly used for the main heading, but if this is part of a larger site, ensure that there are no multiple <h1> elements on the page.

  ---

  2. Is it accessible, and what improvements could be made?

  Fairly accessible, but some improvements could be made.

  Good points:

  • Correct use of semantic tags.
  • The alt attribute is present for the image (alt="Qr"), which helps screen readers.

  Recommended improvements:

  • The alt text should be more descriptive, such as "QR code linking to Frontend Mentor", to provide better context.
  • Adding aria-labels or role="img" to improve accessibility further.
  • Ensure sufficient contrast between text and background colors for readability.

  ---

  3. Does the layout look good on a range of screen sizes?

  Yes, but some adjustments could enhance responsiveness.

  • The use of flexbox ensures that the QR code container is centered and adapts to different screen sizes.

  Potential improvements:

  • The .qr-code width is fixed at 300px. Instead, using max-width: 90% with a min-width could make it more fluid on smaller screens.
  • The h1 and p text could have better spacing adjustments on very small screens to prevent crowding.

  ---

  4. Is the code well-structured, readable, and reusable?

  Yes, it is structured well, but some refinements could be made.

  • The use of CSS variables (--color-background, etc.) improves maintainability and reusability.

  Suggestions for better readability and reusability:

  • Remove the extra space in <link rel=" stylesheet" href="./styles.css" type="text/css" />, as it might cause loading issues.
  • Keeping the paragraph text (<p>) in a single element rather than splitting it into two would enhance readability and avoid unnecessary markup.

  ---

  5. Does the solution differ considerably from the design?

  No, it stays close to the expected design.

  • The QR code component maintains the expected structure and alignment.
  • The styling closely matches the typical Frontend Mentor design expectations.

  ---

  Final Verdict

  Strong solution overall with a clean structure and good responsiveness.
  Minor improvements in accessibility, responsiveness, and markup structure could make it even better. 🚀

  0
• 

  VikVas28•10

  @VikVas28Posted 15 days ago

  The margins of the title should be smaller. And add width to the texts. To bring them together a little so that they are not so spread out. Play with percentages and additionally set margin right and margin left to auto so that the text is in the middle.

  0