Frontend Mentor | QR code component

Community feedback

• 

  P

  Hussein :)•110

  @DevHusseinPosted 15 days ago

  Please let me know if you have any comments to me! Thanks

  0
• 

  qutubahmed732•90

  @qutubahmed732Posted 15 days ago

  To give high-quality, constructive feedback on a solution with these criteria, here’s how you might break down your evaluation:

  1. Semantic HTML

  • Check if semantic elements like <header>, <footer>, <main>, <section>, <nav>, <article>, and <aside> are used properly. These help screen readers and search engines understand the page structure.
  • Ensure buttons and links are used appropriately. If a button is doing navigation, it should be a link instead, while buttons should be used for actions.
  • If there’s a form, make sure the solution uses <label> tags associated with each input for accessibility.

  2. Accessibility

  • Alt attributes should be present and descriptive for all images.
  • Make sure color contrasts meet WCAG standards. Tools like Contrast Checker can help verify this.
  • Keyboard navigation: Test if all interactive elements are reachable and usable via keyboard, especially for screen reader compatibility.
  • ARIA attributes: If the project includes dynamic elements (like modals or carousels), ensure that ARIA attributes are properly used to inform screen readers about these components.

  3. Responsive Layout

  • Test the layout on a range of screen sizes: small screens (phones), medium screens (tablets), and large screens (desktops).
  • Breakpoint consistency: Check if content reflows gracefully without breaking or causing horizontal scroll on different screens.
  • Touch target size: Make sure buttons and interactive elements are large enough to be tapped easily on mobile devices.

  4. Code Quality

  • Look for consistent indentation and clear organization in the HTML, CSS, and JavaScript (or any scripting language used).
  • Naming conventions in classes and IDs should be consistent, meaningful, and easy to understand.
  • Evaluate if the solution is modular and reusable. For example, CSS classes or JavaScript functions should be created in a way that makes them easy to adapt and reuse.
  • Avoid repetition by ensuring that common styles are applied through classes instead of inline or repetitive code blocks.

  5. Design Consistency

  • Compare the final solution to the original design mockup to ensure visual fidelity. Look at elements like spacing, alignment, typography, and color use.
  • Font choices and sizes should match the design, and there should be consistency in styling across similar components.
  • Ensure attention to detail, especially with elements like hover effects, active states, and focus states, which add polish to the design.

  Additional Tips

  • Encourage continuous improvement by mentioning any areas where best practices or alternative approaches could benefit the solution.
  • Provide positive reinforcement for areas done well. Highlighting strengths can be just as helpful as constructive criticism.

  Using this framework to provide feedback will help guide the developer toward creating a polished, accessible, and maintainable solution.

  0